Rule 1 Reviewed

All our rules are tio be reviewed every year - give your thoughts - the good the bad and the ugly - lets hear it all! but remember - we should wait to see how the game plays before we make
drastic changes - but doesnt hurt to start the discussion now!


Rule 1

• 4th Down, Punting & Kicking
  If the ball is scrimaged on your 49 (or closer to your end), you must punt on 4th down. Only exceptions:
  a) You are behind three scores at anytime during the game
  b) You are behind in the 4th quarter
  
  On the extra point or field goal inside the 20 Rule you cannot manually control or manipulate any players.
  
  Squib kicks are only allowed in the last minute of the 2nd and 4th quarter.
  
  Surprise onside kicks are allowed but only one every few games.
  
  'Tactic-ing' every third game (or more) is strongly prohibited.
  
  An
  onside kick where you punch it 11 yards slightly to the kicking foot
  side and up the middle is prohibited and a known glitch (i.e. the onside
  kick were you aim as far as you can opposite side to the surpise onside
  kick direction and pooch the ball 11 yards ahead straight ahead of the
  kicker).
  
  Note: When receiving a punt you are not allowed to
  take an extra blocker off the D-Line and bring him back near the punt
  returner. You are allowed to bring a player back beside the kicker or
  move the players over-top of the Kick coverage team's gunners.
  
  
  </li>
  

No need for changes here IMO

My opinion tho is in the NFL you will often have a 2nd guy back to block etc on punts.... I see nothing at all wrong with manually controlling a guy and bringing him back as an extra blocker on punts...
Nothing not sim about doing it imo...

Everything else though makes sense and I agree with here...

I second Trumps statement. I don't see it abusing game mechanics or being glitchy.

JUST LEAVE IT BE.

If you drop a guy back it messes with the man to man the punt teams blocker would use say you drop back a cb ..that's fine but the middle if where the pint team will still focus on blocking ppl ..and you will gain an extra man ..

Almost feel like 11 v 10 as the man blocking adjustments just tell the lineman to just help or block some1 else near the Line.. Gunners would face an extra man ..